Journal Search Engine
Search Advanced Search Adode Reader(link)
Download PDF Export Citaion korean bibliography PMC previewer
ISSN : 1229-3431(Print)
ISSN : 2287-3341(Online)
Journal of the Korean Society of Marine Environment and Safety Vol.32 No.4 pp.697-707
DOI : https://doi.org/10.7837/kosomes.2026.32.4.697

Authentic-Data-Based Approach to Prioritising VTS Operator Communication Training

Seung-Hee Choi*, Unkyu Jang**†
*Associate Professor, Navigation Department, Korea Institute of Maritime and Fisheries Technology, Busan, 49111, Korea
**Professor, Navigation Department, Korea Institute of Maritime and Fisheries Technology, Busan, 49111, Korea

* First Author : eng1017@hanmail.net, 051-620-5737


† Corresponding Author : sirius4600@gmail.com, 051-620-5800
July 15, 2026 August 7, 2026 August 28, 2026

Abstract


Vessel Traffic Service (VTS) operator communication training cannot be based on standardised phraseology alone. Prescribed forms do not indicate which communication functions, interactional patterns, or communicative actions occur most frequently or place recurrent demands on operators in real time. This study uses authentic Very High Frequency (VHF) radio communication data to derive priorities for VTS operator communication training. The data comprise 2,379 communication cases recorded over three consecutive days at Ulsan Port, Republic of Korea. The recordings were manually transcribed and analysed within a genre-based framework, in which each case was assigned to one of 20 functional categories and each exchange was segmented into turns and coded for moves, steps, and strategies. The 20 categories were grouped into five operational domains, and the analysis examined frequency, reporting-and-confirmation, failed contact and non-routine communication, and strategy-level actions. Recorded communication was concentrated in routine port movement and navigational information or traffic organisation. Reporting-and-confirmation accounted for nearly half of the recorded communication, indicating that report handling and operational updating place recurrent communicative demands on VTS operators. Failed contact, unintelligible communication, and uncategorised communication identified non-routine channel-management competence as a further priority.



실제 VHF 교신 데이터 기반 VTS 관제사 의사소통 훈련 우선순위 도출 연구

최승희*, 장은규**†
*한국해양수산연수원 부교수
**한국해양수산연수원 교수

초록


본 연구는 실제 VHF 교신 데이터에 기반하여 VTS 관제사 의사소통 훈련에서 우선적으로 다루어야 할 훈련 영역과 과업 구성요소를 도출하는 것을 목적으로 한다. 이를 위해 대한민국 울산항에서 3일 연속 수집된 VHF 교신 2,379건을 분석하였다. 녹취 자료는 수작업으로 전사하였으며, 각 교신 사례를 20개 기능 범주로 분류하고, 개별 교신을 turn 단위로 분할한 뒤 move, step, strategy 수준에서 코딩하는 장르 기반 분석틀을 적용하였다. 분석 결과, 실제 VTS 교신은 소수의 운영 영역에 집중되어 있었으며, 항만 이동 관련 교신과 항행 정보·교통 조직 교신이 핵심적인 교신 영역으로 나타났다. 보고-확인 교신은 전체 교신의 거의 절반을 차지하였으며, 이는 짧은 무선 보고의 정확한 수신, 정보 충분성 판단, 간결한 확인, 교통상황 및 관제 기록 반영이 VTS 관제사에게 반복적으로 요구되는 의사소통 부담임을 보여준다. 또한 최초 호출 무응답, 판독 불가 교신, 미분류 교신은 각각 응답 없는 호출에 대한 대응, 불명확한 수신에 대한 처리, 정형화되지 않은 교신 상황에 대한 판단을 비정형 채널 관리 역량의 일부로 다룰 필요가 있음을 보여주었다. 한편 세부 전략(strategy) 수준의 분석은 시나리오 기반 훈련 과업에 포함되어야 할 구체적인 정보 항목과 의사소통 행위를 제시하였다. 이러한 결과는 VTS 관제사 의사소통 훈련이 표준 표현의 반복 연습을 넘어, 실제 교신에서 반복되는 운영 영역, 보고 처리 과정, 비정형 교신 상황, 세부 정보 처리 행위를 반영한 시나리오 기반 과업으로 설계될 필요가 있음을 시사한다.



    1. Introduction

    Vessel Traffic Service (VTS) operator communication is a central component of port traffic management and safe navigation. Through VHF radio, VTSOs and vessels establish contact, exchange operational information, organise traffic, provide navigational information, issue instructions, and confirm the receipt of messages (IMO, 2021;IALA, 2022). This communication is conducted under demanding operational conditions: the VHF channel is shared, continuously monitored, technologically mediated, and dependent on verbal interaction alone (Boström, 2021). For this reason, VTS communication competence is not simply a matter of knowing standard phrases, but of managing recurrent operational exchanges accurately, concisely, and appropriately in real time.

    Traditionally, maritime communication guidance has placed considerable emphasis on standardisation and phraseology. The IMO Standard Marine Communication Phrases (SMCP) provide an important phraseological framework for safety-related ship-to-ship and ship-to-shore communication (IMO, 2001), while IALA guidance on VTS voice communication and phraseology further specifies how VTS messages should be structured and delivered (IALA, 2022). Such instruments are essential for promoting clarity and consistency. However, they do not by themselves determine what should be prioritised in VTS operator communication training. Training time is limited, and not all communication functions occur with the same frequency, carry the same interactional burden, or require the same communicative response from the VTSO. A training programme based only on prescribed phraseology may therefore miss the patterns that dominate actual VHF channel activity.

    To move from prescribed communication norms to training priorities, therefore, it is necessary to examine authentic VTS radio communication. Actual VHF exchanges can show which communication functions occur most frequently, which interactional patterns place repeated demands on VTSOs, where contact is not completed, and what kinds of communicative actions must be handled in routine operations.

    Accordingly, the present study analyses 2,379 VHF communication cases collected over three consecutive days at Ulsan Port, Republic of Korea, with the aim of deriving priorities for VTS operator communication training. In this study, training priority does not refer to a direct ranking based on frequency alone. Rather, it refers to the training-relevant interpretation of recurrent communicative workload, operational function, interactional demand, recovery needs, and strategy-level communicative actions observed in the recorded communication. The study does not evaluate a training programme, measure learning outcomes, or claim training effectiveness. On this basis, the study addresses the following research questions:

    • (1) What recurrent communication functions in authentic VTS radio communication should be prioritised for VTS operator communication training?

    • (2) What interactional patterns, including reporting-and-confirmation and failed contact, should inform the design of VTS communication training tasks?

    • (3) How can frequency, interactional patterns, and strategy-level actions be used to derive training priorities for VTS operators?

    2. Literature Review

    2.1 VTS communication competence and phraseology-based guidance

    VTS radio communication is a form of safety-critical workplace communication conducted under demanding operational constraints. International instruments define VTS as a service that contributes to the safety and efficiency of navigation and to the protection of the marine environment (IMO, 2021), and identify communication, traffic organisation, and information exchange as central to its provision (IALA, 2017;2022). In practice, these functions are realised through radio exchanges in which VTSOs receive situation reports, organise traffic, provide navigational information, issue instructions, confirm receipt, and manage safety-related interaction (IALA, 2022;Costa et al., 2018).

    The operational setting of VHF radiotelephony makes these exchanges interactionally complex. The VHF channel is shared by multiple users, must be continuously monitored, relies on voice alone, and does not allow simultaneous talk; as a result, turn-taking and the management of communicative trouble are necessarily constrained (Boström, 2021). These constraints mean that VTSO communication competence extends beyond the production of appropriate expressions to include monitoring ongoing channel activity, recognising the type of exchange unfolding, selecting operationally relevant information, managing the timing and sequence of turns, securing confirmation, and responding appropriately when contact is unsuccessful, weak, or unclear. In addition to these channel constraints, previous studies have also shown that differences among participants in linguistic background, professional role, local knowledge, and familiarity with port-specific routines shape VTS communication in practice (Bocanegra-Valle, 2011;Costa et al., 2018).

    Against this background, VTS operator communication training is generally shaped by international guidance on VTS functions, voice communication, and standardised phraseology. The IMO Standard Marine Communication Phrases provide a widely recognised framework for safety-related ship-to-ship and ship-to-shore communication (IMO, 2001), while IALA guidance on VTS voice communication and phraseology specifies how VTS messages should be structured and delivered (IALA, 2022). Such resources remain essential for safe, concise, and procedurally consistent radio practice. However, from a training-design perspective, standardised phraseology and international guidance do not by themselves indicate which communication functions should receive the most practice, which interactional problems should be explicitly addressed, or how different communication situations should be represented in training scenarios. VTS operator communication training therefore requires not only prescribed forms and procedural guidance, but also empirical evidence of how VTS communication is actually organised in operational settings.

    2.2 Authentic VHF communication as a basis for training-priority setting

    This need for empirical evidence directs attention to authentic VHF communication. Prescribed phraseology can define recommended forms, but authentic radio data show how communication is actually organised in operational settings. Previous research has shown that maritime VHF exchanges contain recurrent stages, repairs, non-responses, and departures from recommended forms (Bocanegra-Valle, 2011;Boström, 2021). Studies of VTS operation have also shown that non-technical communication factors, including assumptions about shared knowledge and decisions about what to transmit or withhold, shape VTSO communication in practice (Brödje et al., 2013;Costa et al., 2018). Such findings indicate that VTS operator communication training should be informed not only by expected message forms, but also by the recurrent interactional patterns found in actual radio communication.

    For training-priority setting, this evidence matters in two respects. VTS guidance covers multiple communicative functions, including information exchange, traffic organisation, confirmation, and safety-related message delivery, while studies of maritime VHF communication show that these functions are realised through recurrent but interactionally constrained exchanges (Bocanegra-Valle, 2011;IALA, 2017;2022;Boström, 2021). Training design is therefore unlikely to be well served by treating all communication functions as equivalent. Routine exchanges, such as arrival, departure, movement, berthing, and reporting/passing, require attention not only as operationally necessary communication, but also as recurrent exchanges that can create cumulative channel workload when repeated across daily operations (Costa et al., 2018;IALA, 2022). Less predictable situations, such as failed contact, repeated calling, unclear reception, and safety-related instruction, also require attention, as they involve monitoring, recovery, and confirmation. Previous studies of maritime radio and VTS operation have shown that communicative trouble, repair, assumptions about shared knowledge, and non-technical communication factors can shape how maritime communication is managed in practice (Boström, 2021;Brödje et al., 2013;Costa et al., 2018). If training treats all communication categories as equivalent, high-frequency routine work and recurrent trouble-management situations can be underrepresented in task design.

    From this perspective, authentic-data-based analysis can contribute to VTS operator communication training by making three kinds of training-relevant evidence visible: frequency analysis can indicate which communication functions should become the focus of repeated practice; interactional-pattern analysis can show how routine reporting, confirmation, failed contact, unclear reception, and non-routine exchanges are organised in actual VHF communication; and strategy-level analysis can reveal the recurring information items and communicative actions around which practical training tasks can be organised. In this way, authentic VHF data can help connect prescribed communication forms with the operational patterns that VTSOs repeatedly encounter in practice.

    2.3 Genre analysis and ESP approaches to workplace communication training

    To connect authentic communication patterns with training priorities, an analytical framework is needed that can describe both the purpose and the structure of workplace communication. Genre analysis, developed within English for Specific Purposes (ESP), provides such a framework by treating language as a resource for accomplishing recurrent communicative purposes in specific professional settings (Swales, 1990). Rather than analysing expressions in isolation, genre analysis examines how communication is organised into recognisable moves and steps, and how these structures are realised through recurrent linguistic and rhetorical choices (Bhatia, 1993). This orientation makes genre analysis suitable for examining VTS radio communication as operational discourse rather than as a list of separate phrases.

    In maritime communication research, this genre-based perspective has been useful for describing the staged organisation of VHF exchanges and the information requirements associated with maritime radio communication (Bocanegra-Valle, 2011). Related interactional research has also shown that maritime radio exchanges involve repair, clarification, and the management of communicative trouble, indicating that authentic VHF communication is not fully captured by prescribed phraseology alone (Boström, 2021). In the VTS context, studies of non-technical communication factors further show that VTSO communication is shaped by operational judgement, local practice, and decisions about what information should be transmitted, withheld, monitored, or confirmed (Brödje et al., 2013;Costa et al., 2018). Taken together, this body of work supports an approach in which VTS communication is analysed as recurrent, structured, and operationally situated workplace interaction.

    For VTS operator communication training, the value of genre analysis lies in its ability to translate authentic communication into training-relevant categories. This follows from the ESP view that specialised communication can be analysed through recurrent communicative purposes and staged structures, and from maritime VHF research showing that radio exchanges can be described in terms of recurrent communicative patterns and discourse features (Swales, 1990;Bhatia, 1993;Bocanegra-Valle, 2011). A move-step-strategy analysis can therefore show what communicative work is performed in a given exchange: a reporting exchange can involve contact, report delivery, acknowledgement, and confirmation; a failed-contact sequence can involve repeated calling, recipient verification, and continued monitoring; and an instruction-giving exchange can require information delivery, directed action, and confirmation securing (IALA, 2022;Boström, 2021;Brödje et al., 2013;Costa et al., 2018). These patterns are useful for training design, as practical tasks can be organised around recurrent communicative purposes and information items rather than around isolated expressions.

    Existing research has clarified the importance of standardised phraseology, communicative trouble, repair, and non-technical communication factors in maritime and VTS communication. However, less attention has been paid to how authentic VHF communication data can be systematically converted into training-priority evidence for VTS operator communication training. The contribution of the present study lies in using a bounded corpus of authentic VHF communication to identify recurrent functions, interactional patterns, and strategy-level communicative actions that can inform training-priority interpretation. Genre analysis is used for this purpose as an analytical means of connecting authentic operational communication with training-design decisions, rather than as a new methodology or as an evaluation of training effectiveness.

    3. Methods

    3.1 Data source and corpus

    The data consist of three consecutive days of VHF recordings collected in 2016 from a single VHF channel at Ulsan Port, Republic of Korea. The recordings were provided to the research team by the Korea Coast Guard for research purposes. The dataset represents all communications conducted on the recorded channel over the three-day period and comprises 2,379 communication cases. All recordings were manually transcribed into an electronic format for linguistic analysis. The transcribed material amounts to 156,750 syllables in Korean and 10,817 words, or tokens, in English. The present analysis focused on communication cases, functional categories, and move-step-strategy coding; total speaking time, day/night distribution, and case-level language-use ratios were not separately coded as analytical variables.

    A communication case was defined as one analytically bounded VHF exchange organised around a single operational purpose, such as a call, report, request, instruction, confirmation, or information exchange. Where an initiating call received no response, the call sequence was coded as one non-response case. Where several turns occurred between the vessel station and the VTS centre, the exchange was treated as one case when the turns formed a single operationally coherent communicative event.

    The VHF communication data used in this study were first introduced in a conference proceeding presented at IMEC 2017 (Choi et al., 2017). The present article reanalyses the data for a different research purpose, namely deriving priorities for VTS operator communication training. This dataset was suitable for the present study for two reasons. It contains authentic ship–shore and related radio communication from an operational VTS environment, rather than elicited or classroom-based discourse. It also covers a complete short period of activity on the recorded channel, allowing recurrent communication functions, failed contact, non-routine exchanges, and strategy-level communicative actions to be examined as part of ordinary VTS work. The analysis was therefore conducted with the aim of identifying training-relevant patterns in actual VHF communication, while recognising that the data represent one port and one VHF channel.

    3.2 Genre-based coding of VTS communication

    The transcribed data were analysed using a genre-based framework. This framework follows the genre-analytic tradition in which professional communication is examined in relation to recurrent communicative purposes, staged structures, and linguistic realisations (Swales, 1990;Bhatia, 1993), and is also consistent with genre-oriented analyses of maritime radiotelephony and VHF communication (Bocanegra-Valle, 2011).

    The analytical procedure involved three linked stages. The communication cases were categorised according to informational relevance and operational function, yielding 20 functional categories such as pilotage, departure, arrival, and reporting or passing. Each communication case was then segmented into turns. Each turn was subsequently analysed in terms of moves, steps, and strategies.

    In this framework, a turn refers to a single speaker contribution. A move refers to a communicative stage that serves a particular purpose, such as calling, ship identification, or pilotage. A step refers to a smaller action through which a move is realised, such as requesting information or acknowledging receipt. A strategy refers to the most delicate unit of analysis, corresponding to the specific information item or communicative action conveyed by the speaker, such as call sign, pilot boarding time, or contact channel.

    A single turn can contain more than one communicative action, so such turns were divided into separate coded lines where necessary. Table 1 therefore clarifies how the analysis moved from observable radio turns to progressively more specific units of communicative meaning. This procedure allowed the analysis to identify both broad operational functions and more detailed communicative actions within each exchange, providing the basis for the frequency, interactional-pattern, and strategy-level analyses reported in the following sections.

    3.3 Methodological scope and limitations

    Several methodological limitations should be noted. The data were drawn from a single port and covered only three consecutive days of communication on one recorded VHF channel; therefore, the dataset does not cover all VHF channels used in Ulsan Port.

    These limitations restrict the generalisability of the findings, but do not remove the value of the dataset for the present purpose. The aim of this study is not to produce a comprehensive account of all VTS communication in Ulsan Port or to evaluate the effectiveness of a training programme. Rather, the study uses a bounded corpus of authentic VHF communication to identify recurrent communication functions, reporting-and-confirmation patterns, failed contact and non-routine communication, and strategy-level actions that can inform the prioritisation of VTS operator communication training. The findings should therefore be interpreted as evidence of recurrent communicative patterns in a bounded operational corpus, rather than as a comprehensive account of VTS communication across different ports and channels. The present study focused on communication cases, functional categories, interactional patterns, and strategy-level communicative actions; future studies could extend this approach by incorporating multi-port datasets, temporal variables, and language-use variables.

    4. Results and discussion

    4.1 Functional concentration and training-priority interpretation

    The analysis identified 20 functional categories of VTS radio communication in the recorded Ulsan Port data. For training-priority interpretation, these categories were grouped into five broader operational domains: arrival, departure, berthing, unberthing, and movement; navigational information and traffic organisation; failed contact and non-routine communication; anchoring-related communication; and pilotage-related communication. Frequency is not treated here as the sole determinant of training priority. Rather, it is used as an indicator of recurrent communicative workload in the recorded VTS channel. Training-priority interpretation therefore considers frequency together with operational function, interactional demand, and the communicative actions required within each exchange. Low-frequency but high-risk situations may require substantial training attention, but risk severity and safety impact were not directly measured in the present dataset.

    Taken together, Table 2 and Fig. 1 show that recorded VTS communication was not evenly distributed across operational domains. The visual distribution in Fig. 1 makes this concentration particularly clear: the two largest domains, arrival/departure/berthing/unberthing/movement and navigational information/traffic organisation, accounted for more than half of all recorded communication. The largest domain was arrival, departure, berthing, unberthing, and movement, with 723 cases, accounting for 30.40% of all recorded communication. This was followed by navigational information and traffic organisation, with 625 cases, accounting for 26.30%. Together, these two domains accounted for 56.70% of the dataset. This concentration indicates that more than half of the recorded channel activity was associated with either routine port movement or the organisation of navigational and traffic information.

    This pattern provides a more specific basis for training-priority interpretation. The concentration of cases in the two largest domains is not only a quantitative result. When the categories included in these domains are examined more closely, the distribution points to two recurrent patterns of VTS communicative work: reporting-oriented communication and VTS-active communication. Reporting-oriented communication is represented by the arrival, departure, berthing, unberthing, and movement domain, where vessels report their operational status and the VTSO identifies the vessel, recognises the reported state, acknowledges receipt, and keeps the channel sequence moving without unnecessary delay. VTS-active communication is represented by the navigational information and traffic organisation domain, where the VTSO provides navigational information, organises traffic flow, issues instructions where necessary, and secures confirmation. The two largest domains therefore point to a core training area that combines rapid handling of vessel-initiated routine reports with repeated and systematic practice in VTS-active traffic organisation.

    The third-largest domain, failed contact and non-routine communication, accounted for 496 cases, or 20.80% of all recorded communication, indicating that training-priority interpretation should not be reduced to routine communication alone. A substantial part of the recorded channel activity involved failed, non-routine, or less easily classifiable communication, and this domain therefore points to the need for training tasks that prepare VTSOs to manage uncertainty, non-response, unclear contact, and flexible recovery, rather than only rehearsing well-formed standard exchanges.

    Anchoring-related communication accounted for 325 cases, or 13.70% of all recorded communication, and its training relevance lies in both its frequency and its operational depth. Although this domain was smaller than the two largest domains, it still represented a substantial single area of communication in the dataset. In the present dataset, anchoring-related communication included anchor reports, heaving-up-anchor communication, anchorage-related information, position-related confirmation, and information such as the number of shackles. These categories show that anchoring-related communication is not a single routine report, but a continuity-based state-tracking domain in which VTSOs must follow changes in a vessel’s operational state, from being underway to being anchored and then to preparing for, or conducting, heaving-up-anchor operations. From a training-priority perspective, this domain therefore requires more than brief coverage of anchoring-related expressions. Its relative frequency and operational complexity support dedicated training time and deeper scenario-based practice in which VTSOs recognise changes in vessel state, confirm anchorage-related details, and connect this information with surrounding traffic movements as part of continuous traffic management.

    Pilotage-related communication accounted for 210 cases, or 8.83% of all recorded communication, making it the least frequent of the five domains; however, its lower frequency should be interpreted together with the complexity of the communicative environment in which pilotage arrangements are handled. In the present dataset, pilotage-related exchanges included communication between the VTSO and a vessel, between a pilot boat and a vessel, and among operational participants involved in pilotage arrangements. This pattern indicates that pilotage-related communication is not simply a set of pilotage phrases, but a multi-party communication environment in which time-sensitive information must be tracked across participants. From a training-priority perspective, this domain therefore requires scenario-based practice in which VTSOs monitor pilot boarding time, boarding arrangements, contact channels, participant roles, and confirmation points, while maintaining awareness of how pilotage arrangements affect the wider traffic situation.

    Overall, the domain-level distribution supports a tiered approach to VTS operator communication training. The highest-frequency domains provide the empirical basis for core training in reporting-oriented communication and VTS-active traffic organisation, while the substantial share of failed contact and non-routine communication supports explicit training in recovery and non-routine channel management. Anchoring-related communication further highlights the need for training in continuity-based state tracking and confirmation, whereas pilotage-related communication points to multi-party and time-sensitive information monitoring as a specialised training focus. Frequency analysis therefore contributes not by producing a simple ranking of importance, but by showing how different communication domains can be positioned within a balanced training-priority framework.

    4.2 Reporting-and-confirmation as report-handling and operational updating competence

    The domain-level analysis in Section 4.1 showed that recorded VTS communication was concentrated in a limited number of operational domains. A second layer of analysis concerns how these domains were realised interactionally. Across the dataset, a large share of communication followed a reporting-and-confirmation pattern, in which a vessel reported an operational state, movement, or passage-related event and the VTS centre acknowledged or confirmed receipt. This pattern cut across several functional categories rather than belonging to a single operational topic. Fig. 2 therefore presents the reporting-type categories as a cross-domain interactional pattern, rather than as a separate operational domain.

    As Fig. 2 shows, reporting-and-confirmation accounted for 1,085 cases, or 45.61% of all recorded communication. The significance of this distribution lies not simply in the frequency of short report-and-reply exchanges, but in the recurrent processing demand placed on the VTSO. A radio report must be heard accurately, linked to the correct vessel, interpreted in relation to the vessel’s operational state, judged for sufficiency, confirmed concisely, and connected to the wider traffic picture, including operational records where required.

    In this sense, reporting-and-confirmation requires report-handling and operational updating competence: the ability to convert a brief radio report into confirmed operational information. This competence is partly linguistic, as the VTSO must recognise vessel identification, reported status, time, location, movement, and intention from short and sometimes formulaic messages. It is also cognitive and procedural, as the VTSO must decide whether a single confirmation is sufficient, whether additional checking is needed, and how the received information should be connected to subsequent monitoring, record-keeping, and traffic-management decisions.

    The importance of this competence is amplified by the frequency of the pattern: when nearly half of the recorded communication follows a reporting-and-confirmation sequence, even simple exchanges become a major component of VTSO communication work.

    Table 3 translates this reporting-and-confirmation pattern into training-relevant demands by specifying what the VTSO must do within the exchange and how these demands can be reflected in task design.

    As summarised in Table 3, the reporting-and-confirmation pattern suggests that routine reporting should be trained as a compact but information-dense operational sequence. A training task built around departure, arrival, berthing, movement, or anchor reporting should not end with the learner producing a standard acknowledgement. It should require the learner to listen for key information, judge whether the report is complete, decide whether a single confirmation is sufficient, and connect the received information to the next operational action. This approach treats reporting-oriented communication not as low-level phrase practice, but as a recurrent site where listening, confirmation, operational judgement, and procedural follow-through are combined.

    Taken together, the reporting-type categories indicate that report-handling and operational updating competence should occupy a central place in VTS operator communication training. This competence requires VTSOs to convert brief radio reports into confirmed operational information through accurate listening, sufficiency judgement, concise confirmation, operational updating, and connection to subsequent traffic-management decisions. Reporting-and-confirmation should therefore be treated not as low-level phrase practice, but as a core training sequence in which linguistic reception, cognitive judgement, and procedural follow-through are integrated.

    4.3 Failed contact, uncategorised, and unintelligible communication as non-routine channel-management demands

    Section 4.2 examined reporting-and-confirmation as a completed or closable interactional sequence. The present section turns to a different part of the dataset: the failed contact and non-routine communication domain identified in Section 4.1. This domain accounted for 496 cases, or 20.80% of all recorded communication, and was the third-largest operational domain in the dataset. Before considering its training relevance, it is necessary to distinguish the subcategories included in this domain, as they represent different kinds of non-routine channel activity. Table 4 therefore separates failed contact (defined here as non-response to an initiating call), uncategorised communication, and unintelligible communication before their training implications are discussed.

    Table 4 shows that the failed contact and non-routine communication domain was not a single type of communication. It consisted of three different forms of channel activity: failed contact, uncategorised communication, and unintelligible communication. Failed contact places emphasis on repeated calling, contact-status confirmation, and recovery from unanswered calls. Uncategorised communication requires operator judgement in exchanges that fall outside the main operational categories, whereas unintelligible communication requires strategies for handling transmissions that cannot be reliably interpreted from the recording.

    Failed contact accounted for 301 cases, or 12.70% of all recorded communication, and formed the largest subcategory within this domain. Unlike uncategorised or unintelligible communication, failed contact has a clear interactional pattern: a call is made, but the expected response does not follow. The exchange therefore stops at the opening stage, before any operational message can be delivered, acknowledged, or confirmed.

    This pattern creates a distinct training issue. In a completed reporting-and-confirmation exchange, the VTSO receives information, judges whether it is sufficient, and closes the exchange with an appropriate confirmation. In a failed-contact sequence, however, the VTSO must first manage the absence of response and restore the conditions for information exchange. The training priority is therefore recovery-oriented communication competence: the ability to recognise that the expected contact sequence has not been completed, maintain orientation to the intended recipient, decide when and how to repeat the call, verify the recipient when contact is restored, continue monitoring the shared VHF channel while the response is absent, and return the exchange to an operationally useful sequence once contact is re-established.

    Unintelligible communication points to the need for intelligibility management, although this category should be interpreted with care. In the present dataset, unintelligible communication referred to transmissions that could not be reliably interpreted from the recording; it therefore cannot be treated as direct evidence of every listening difficulty faced by VTSOs in real-time operation. Even with this limitation, the category remains training-relevant. VTS communication training should not be based only on clean, fully audible, and perfectly articulated samples. Learners need exposure to realistic communication conditions in which parts of a message are difficult to hear, pronunciation is unclear, audio quality is degraded, or the message cannot be fully processed on first hearing. Training tasks should therefore include degraded but operationally plausible communication samples, requiring learners to avoid premature confirmation, request repetition or clarification, check uncertain information, and manage the exchange until the message is sufficiently understood for operational use.

    Uncategorised communication points to possible communication needs that fall outside the main operational categories. Although this subcategory accounted for only 158 cases, or 6.64% of all recorded communication, it shows that the shared VHF channel can include miscellaneous requests or exchanges that do not fit neatly into standard VTS communication categories. These exchanges should not be elevated to the same training priority as high-frequency reporting, traffic organisation, or failed contact. However, they indicate that VTSOs also need a principle-based response to communication that falls outside standard operational categories. Training should therefore help learners recognise such communication needs, decide whether they require monitoring, acknowledgement, redirection, or no immediate action, and apply consistent judgement without allowing non-routine exchanges to distract from the wider traffic situation.

    Taken together, the subcategories in Table 4 show that the failed contact and non-routine communication domain should not be treated as a residual category with limited training value. Failed contact requires recovery-oriented communication competence, unintelligible communication requires intelligibility management under degraded communication conditions, and uncategorised communication requires a principle-based response to miscellaneous communication needs. The training priority derived from this domain is therefore non-routine channel-management competence: the ability to manage unanswered calls, unclear transmissions, and non-routine channel activity while maintaining awareness of the wider traffic situation.

    4.4 Strategy-level communicative actions as scenario-design elements

    The preceding sections identified training priorities at the level of operational domains and interactional patterns. A further layer of evidence is provided by strategy-level communicative actions. The coding identified 558 recurrent strategy-level items and actions that specify what information must be extracted, confirmed, corrected, or operationally applied within VHF exchanges. In the present analysis, strategies refer to the most specific information items or communicative actions conveyed within a turn, such as CPA and number of shackles. These items are important for training design, as they show what learners must actually notice, process, confirm, or produce within scenario-based communication tasks.

    Strategy-level analysis helps translate broad communication categories into teachable scenario components. In reporting-oriented communication, learners need to identify vessel identity, movement status, location, time, and intention from compact reports. In VTS-active traffic organisation, scenario tasks should include information items such as CPA, current speed, passing point, destination, and additional navigational information. In anchoring-related communication, training tasks should include anchorage status, heaving-up-anchor information, position-related confirmation, and number of shackles. In pilotage-related communication, tasks should include pilot boarding time, boarding arrangements, contact channel, and confirmation points. In failed or unclear communication, strategy-level actions such as repetition, correction, clarification, and confirmation become central to recovery and intelligibility management.

    The training value of strategy-level analysis therefore lies in its ability to specify the internal content of scenario tasks. Frequency analysis can show which domains deserve attention, and interactional-pattern analysis can show how exchanges are organised, but strategy-level analysis shows what information and communicative actions must be handled inside those exchanges. VTS operator communication training should therefore use strategy-level evidence to design tasks that require learners to extract, confirm, correct, and operationally apply specific information items, rather than only practise complete phrases or generic exchange patterns.

    5. Conclusion

    This study analysed 2,379 authentic VHF communication cases recorded at Ulsan Port to derive training-priority evidence for VTS operator communication training. The analysis does not treat frequency as the sole basis for training priority. Instead, training-priority interpretation was based on recurrent communicative workload, operational function, interactional demand, recovery needs, and strategy-level communicative actions identified in the recorded communication.

    The findings show that recorded VTS communication was concentrated in a limited number of operational domains, particularly routine port movement and navigational information or traffic organisation. This concentration indicates areas in which operators repeatedly process short, operationally relevant exchanges. Reporting-and-confirmation was especially prominent, suggesting that report handling, sufficiency judgement, concise confirmation, and operational updating should be reflected in training tasks. Failed contact, unintelligible communication, and uncategorised communication further indicate that non-routine channel-management demands should be incorporated into VTS communication training.

    The strategy-level analysis identified 558 recurrent communicative items and actions, including the extraction, confirmation, correction, and operational application of key information. These items provide a practical basis for designing scenario-based tasks that move beyond phrase repetition and require learners to process information, make interactional decisions, and connect communication to the wider traffic situation.

    The study has several limitations. The data were drawn from one VHF channel at one port, and the findings should therefore be interpreted as evidence of recurrent communicative patterns in a bounded operational corpus rather than as a comprehensive account of VTS communication across different ports and channels. The study also did not measure safety impact, risk severity, training effectiveness, learning outcomes, total speaking time, day/night distribution, or case-level language-use ratios. Future studies could extend this approach by incorporating multi-port datasets, temporal and language-use variables, and risk-related weighting of low-frequency but safety-critical communication situations.

    Figure

    KOSOMES-32-4-697_F1.jpg

    Domain-level distribution of recorded VTS communication (number of cases and percentage share).

    KOSOMES-32-4-697_F2.jpg

    Distribution of reporting-type communication categories within reporting-and-confirmation exchanges (n = 1,085; 45.61% of all recorded communication).

    Table

    Example of genre-based coding of VTS communication

    Operational domains of recorded VTS communication and training-relevant interpretation

    Training-relevant demands within reporting-and-confirmation exchanges

    Subcategories of failed contact and non-routine communication

    Reference

    1. Bhatia, V. K. ( 1993), Analysing Genre: Language Use in Professional Settings, Longman, London.
    2. Bocanegra-Valle, A. ( 2011), The Language of Seafaring: Standardized Conventions and Discursive Features in Speech Communications, International Journal of English Studies, Vol. 11, No. 1, pp. 35-53.
    3. Boström, M. ( 2021), Other-initiated Repair as an Indicator of Critical Communication in Ship-to-ship Interaction, Journal of Pragmatics, Vol. 174, pp. 78-92.
    4. Brödje, A., M.Lundh, J.Jenvald, and J.Dahlman ( 2013), Exploring Non-technical Miscommunication in Vessel Traffic Service Operation, Cognition, Technology & Work, Vol. 15, No. 3, pp. 347-357.
    5. Choi, S. H., E. K.Chang, E.Frendo, and J.Lee ( 2017), Consideration on the Standardised Communication Phrases for e-Navigation, Proceedings of the 29th International Maritime English Conference (IMEC 29), Korea Institute of Maritime and Fisheries Technology, Busan, Republic of Korea, 23–27 October 2017, pp. 272-286.
    6. Costa, N. A., M.Lundh, and S. N.MacKinnon ( 2018), Non-technical Communication Factors at the Vessel Traffic Services, Cognition, Technology & Work, Vol. 20, No. 1, pp. 63-72.
    7. IALA ( 2017), Report of the IALA Workshop on Common Phraseology and Procedures for VTS Communication, International Association of Marine Aids to Navigation and Lighthouse Authorities, Saint-Germain-en-Laye.
    8. IALA ( 2022), VTS Voice Communications and Phraseology, Guideline G1132, Edition 2.2, International Association of Marine Aids to Navigation and Lighthouse Authorities, Saint-Germain-en-Laye.
    9. IMO ( 2001), IMO Standard Marine Communication Phrases, Resolution A.918(22), International Maritime Organization, London.
    10. IMO ( 2021), Guidelines for Vessel Traffic Services, Resolution A.1158(32), International Maritime Organization, London.
    11. Swales, J. M. ( 1990), Genre Analysis: English in Academic and Research Settings, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.